This question is a trap, but it's a fair one. Every educator knows that cell phones are a constant battle during the school day. Students are glued to screens, sneaking glances under desks, AirPods hidden under hoodies, teachers constantly saying "put that away" for the hundredth time. It's exhausting. It's futile. And it's seen as one of the biggest obstacles to learning.

But here's the thing: cell phones are rarely a problem in after-school activities. Think about it. When was the last time a coach had to confiscate phones during basketball practice? When was the last time a drama director fought with students over texting during rehearsal? When was the last time the robotics club advisor had to beg kids to stop scrolling and focus on building? It doesn't happen. Not because the kids are different, but because the activity is.

In after-school activities, students are doing something they chose to do. They're engaged. They're invested. They care about the outcome. The phone becomes irrelevant because what's happening in front of them matters more than what's on the screen. They're not looking for an escape because they don't want to escape. They want to be there.

During the school day, it's the opposite. Students are in a place they didn't choose, learning things they don't care about, at a pace that doesn't fit them, under rules that feel arbitrary. Of course they reach for their phones. The phone is a lifeline to a world that actually makes sense, where they have agency, connection, and control. It's not that they're addicted. It's that they're bored, disengaged, and trapped. The phone is the only exit available.

This single observation exposes the lie behind so much educational policy. We blame the phones. We ban them. We threaten to take them away. We act like the device is the problem. But the device is just a symptom. The real problem is that what we're offering during the school day isn't compelling enough to compete with a rectangle of light.

After-school activities prove this beyond any doubt. The same kids, the same building, the same time of day—but no phone problem. Why? Because they're doing something they actually want to do. The solution isn't better phone policies. It's better engagement. And you can't force engagement. You can only create conditions where people choose to engage.

So the next time an educator complains about cell phones, ask them this question. Watch them squirm. Because they know the answer. They know that when kids are doing what matters to them, the phones disappear. The only question is why we don't design the whole day that way.

 

Back