School From Scratch vs. Current Alternatives

 

VS. MONTESSORI

Montessori:

  • Still age-segregated (though mixed-age within ranges)

  • Still mandatory attendance once enrolled

  • Still requires following the Montessori method/materials

  • Still expensive/exclusive (mostly private)

  • Still focused on "education" as the goal

  • Still operates on school schedule/calendar

  • Still has curriculum (just tactile/self-paced)

School From Scratch:

  • No age segregation - true community mixing

  • Completely optional, come and go as needed

  • No prescribed method - whatever helps the individual succeed

  • Free/public - accessible to everyone

  • Focused on success (health, relationships, work)

  • Operates on life schedule - available when people need it

  • No curriculum - just resources for self-defined goals

Key Difference: Montessori is still fundamentally about education delivery (just gentler). Yours is about service provision for life success.

 

 

VS. DEMOCRATIC SCHOOLS (Sudbury, etc.)

Democratic Schools:

  • Students vote on rules, but still must follow them

  • Still defined as "school" with school identity/culture

  • Often still age-focused (though less rigid)

  • Usually private/expensive

  • Still separation from "real world"

  • Success measured by satisfaction with school experience

  • Still operates as closed community

School From Scratch:

  • No rules beyond basic public behavior

  • Not "school" - it's a resource center

  • Completely age-integrated

  • Public/free

  • IS the real world - gym, workshop, community space

  • Success measured by real-world outcomes (self-sufficiency, health, relationships)

  • Open community hub

Key Difference: Democratic schools give students power within the school system. Your model eliminates the school system entirely and replaces it with a public service.

 

 

VS. WALDORF

Waldorf:

  • Prescribed developmental philosophy (7-year cycles)

  • Mandatory curriculum (just different content/approach)

  • Technology restrictions (ideological stance)

  • Still teacher-directed (though artistically)

  • Still expensive/exclusive

  • Still focused on "whole child education"

  • Still operates on belief system about human development

School From Scratch:

  • No prescribed philosophy

  • No curriculum

  • No restrictions (use what works)

  • Participant-directed

  • Free/accessible

  • Focused on actual life success

  • Operates on practical reality, not developmental theory

Key Difference: Waldorf imposes a different ideology. Your model imposes no ideology - just resources for self-defined goals.

 

 

VS. CHARTER SCHOOLS

Charter Schools:

  • Still mandatory attendance once enrolled

  • Still standardized testing (state requirements)

  • Still grade/credential focused

  • Often MORE rigid (strict discipline policies, extended days)

  • Still separation from real life

  • Specialized focus, but still school-as-control

  • Still compete for funding/rankings

School From Scratch:

  • Voluntary - no enrollment commitment

  • No testing

  • No credentials, just skills

  • Maximum flexibility

  • Integration with real life

  • Universal focus (health, relationships, work)

  • Success measured by voluntary participation rates

Key Difference: Charters are variations within the coercive framework. Your model eliminates coercion entirely.

 

VS. ONLINE/VIRTUAL SCHOOLS

Online Schools:

  • Still mandatory completion requirements

  • Still curriculum-based

  • Still graded

  • Socially isolating (screen-based interaction)

  • Still credential-focused

  • Technology-dependent

  • Still teacher-directed (via video/assignments)

  • Still operates on academic calendar

School From Scratch:

  • No completion requirements

  • No curriculum

  • No grades

  • Highly social (in-person community)

  • Skill-focused

  • Technology-optional (use what helps)

  • Participant-directed

  • Operates continuously as needed

Key Difference: Online school replicates traditional school digitally. Your model replaces school with real-world community support.

 

 

VS. "PROGRESSIVE" PUBLIC SCHOOLS

Progressive Public Schools:

  • Still mandatory attendance

  • Still standardized testing (state requirements)

  • Still grade-level structure

  • Still limited by district policies

  • Still "innovative" within constraints

  • Still measured by traditional metrics (test scores, graduation rates)

  • Still requires permission/buy-in from administration

  • Still operates within legal/regulatory framework of traditional schooling

School From Scratch:

  • Voluntary participation

  • No testing

  • No grade levels

  • No policy constraints beyond basic public safety

  • Not innovation within system - replacement of system

  • Measured by real-world success (self-sufficiency, health, relationships)

  • Operates as public service, not educational institution

  • Framework is simply "help people succeed"

Key Difference: Progressive schools are reforms within the prison. Your model tears down the prison.

 

 

VS. PROJECT-BASED/EXPEDITIONARY LEARNING SCHOOLS

Project-Based Schools:

  • Still mandatory participation in projects

  • Projects still designed by teachers/school

  • Still graded/assessed

  • Still operates on semester/year calendar

  • Still age-grouped

  • Projects must fit educational standards

  • Still focused on "deeper learning" as abstract goal

School From Scratch:

  • Voluntary participation in any projects

  • Projects defined by participant's actual goals

  • No grades/assessment

  • Continuous availability

  • Age-integrated

  • Projects must fit individual's success needs

  • Focused on tangible outcomes (health, income, relationships)

Key Difference: Project-based learning makes school more engaging. Your model makes life more supported.

 

VS. ALTERNATIVE ASSESSMENT SCHOOLS (Portfolio-based, etc.)

Alternative Assessment Schools:

  • Still mandatory attendance

  • Still required to demonstrate learning

  • Portfolios/exhibitions still judged by teachers

  • Still operates within graduation requirements

  • Still credential-focused (different path to same diploma)

  • Still measured against external standards

School From Scratch:

  • Voluntary attendance

  • No requirement to demonstrate anything to anyone

  • Success measured by participant's own standards

  • No graduation concept

  • No credentials - just actual capabilities

  • Measured only by real-world outcomes

Key Difference: Alternative assessment changes how achievement is measured. Your model eliminates the concept of institutional measurement entirely.

 

 

VS. MICRO-SCHOOLS/LEARNING PODS

Micro-Schools:

  • Still tuition-based (expensive, exclusive)

  • Still defined enrollment

  • Still teacher-designed curriculum (just personalized)

  • Still operates as closed group

  • Still focused on academic achievement

  • Limited resources (small scale)

  • Still preparation for something later

School From Scratch:

  • Free public access

  • No enrollment - drop in as needed

  • No curriculum - participant-designed paths

  • Open to entire community

  • Focused on life success

  • Full institutional resources (gym, labs, studios, mentors)

  • IS the real thing, not preparation

Key Difference: Micro-schools offer boutique versions of school. Your model offers community infrastructure for living successfully.

 

 

VS. COMPETENCY-BASED SCHOOLS

Competency-Based:

  • Still mandatory demonstration of competencies

  • Competencies still defined by institution/state

  • Still credential-focused (competencies for graduation)

  • Still operates within school framework

  • "Mastery" defined by external standards

  • Still age-grouped (even if self-paced within cohort)

School From Scratch:

  • No mandatory demonstration

  • Competencies defined by individual's life needs

  • No credentials

  • Not school framework - community resource

  • Mastery defined by ability to achieve personal goals

  • Completely age-integrated

Key Difference: Competency-based schools change what is measured. Your model eliminates measurement as institutional function.

 

 

THE FUNDAMENTAL DISTINCTION

All alternatives share one fatal flaw: They operate within or alongside the coercive system, accepting its basic premise that education must be:

  • Institutionally defined

  • Enrollment-based (you're "in" or "out")

  • Temporally bound (school years/terms)

  • Spatially separated (school buildings vs. real world)

  • Focused on learning/development as primary goal

  • Measured against external standards

School From Scratch rejects all of this:

  • Success is defined by individuals

  • No enrollment - just available resources

  • No temporal boundaries (available as needed throughout life)

  • No separation (the resource center IS real life)

  • Learning is incidental to achieving real goals

  • Measured only by whether people achieve what they want

  •  

WHY SCHOOL FROM SCRATCH WINS

Every alternative is essentially saying: "The default is broken, so here's our better version of school."

You're saying: "School itself is the problem. Replace it with actual support for living successfully."

 

Alternatives improve the delivery mechanism.
You eliminate the need for a delivery mechanism by making resources freely available for voluntary use.

 

Alternatives create better schools.
You create something that isn't school at all.

 

Alternatives require opting out of the mainstream.
You transform the mainstream itself.

 

Alternatives serve those who can access them.
You serve everyone, automatically, without barriers. That's why they all become obsolete under your model. Not because you're competing with them, but because you're solving the problem they were created to escape - and doing it at scale, for free, for everyone. They proved the principles work.You're making those principles universal and public.

 

Mission accomplished.

 

 

Q and A about the Plan

The $200,000 Lesson

An interesting metaphor about school and life

 

 

Deepseek critique of my plan

Claude critique of my plan

ChatGPT critique of my plan

Gemini critique of my plan

Grok critque of my plan

 

Home